Sint Maarten, Netherlands Antilles: It’s French. No, it’s Dutch. No, French…

It’s Sint Maarten, Netherlands Antilles on one side, and Saint Martin, French West Indies on the other. Weird, right?

We exchanged 60,000 frequent flyer miles for a midnight red-eye to a random Caribbean island. After inconvenient stops in Dallas, Miami, and San Juan, we arrived 14 hours later in balmy Sint Maarten, Antilles (or is it , West Indies?) for a week of R&R (Rum & Reclining).

Sint Maarten is often spelled St. Martin.

Our view of rooms that have a better view.

The Oyster Bay Beach Resort, where we stayed, was a large, modern, but uninspired multi-structure painted light teal. But what the OBBR lacked in old-world charm — and that was plenty — it made up for with clean rooms and nice amenities.

On-property perks included a good-sized infinity pool, a faux-waterfall cascading down into a hot tub, a bar and restaurant, a weight room, a general store. The rooms weren't huge, but they were sufficient, considering no one comes to the tropics to watch TV or order room service.

Despite our best intentions and a blinding tropical sun, we never got up before 11am, and since the sun set emphatically at 6pm, our days were shorter than we would've liked. So we didn't waste any of our precious daylight.

We didn't waste time on Sint Maarten doing stuff.

Mmmm, Caribbean .

We did all the sitting-around-the-pool, sun-tanning, magazine-, and Carib beer drinking humanly possible. The constant tropical breeze off the Caribbean Sea made the 84-degree temperature quite pleasant.

Hanging one's beer off the edge of the resort's infinity pool, one could look over to the island of St. Bart's. St. Bart's is a smaller, but reportedly more snooty, island full of expensive shops and rich, bloated celebrities, one imagines.

Sint Maarten
Le pool. Please, no running.

You can see a lot of other islands from Sint Maarten.

Several other unidentified land masses dotted the azure horizon line, fading off into the distance like so many…uh, half-submerged big rocks. Or something. Hey, it's hard to come up with good similes after a few Caribs. Besides…I'm on .

We couldn't rent my favorite .

Located on the Dutch side, but just barely, the OBBR lay on the far eastern side of the island, away from the noise and commercialism of Phillipsburg as well as the French-ness of Marigot.

It made for a relaxing sense of isolation, that surely would have driven us insane in a “The Shining” sort of way had we not rented a VW Golf for $200 a week (only later did I realize that we could've rented my favorite non-US vehicle, the SmartCar).

On our first day, we stayed “on property” to recoup some sleep lost between San Francisco and Miami. The second day, we decided to explore outside the resort's bar. We hopped into our 1.6L econo-car and headed inland. Finding places on the island seemed daunting at first, but once we discovered that there was only a grand total of about six roads on the whole island, it soon proved pretty simple.

Sint Maarten is the French side of the Dutch island of St. Martin.

Sint Maarten
Our view out the back, Oyster Bay.

At the end of the resort's driveway, there's a sign that says French side/Dutch side with accompanying arrows. The roads are typical of islands — barely paved, single-lane roads with no shoulders, twisting up mountains dangerously close to steep cliffs without warning signs or guard-rails. Despite how fun that sounds, driving in St. Martin is seriously dangerous. And that's what keeps the accident rate low.

On this island, you have to pay attention. And when people pay attention, people don't crash (something we in America have yet to discover). People drive slow around Sint Maarten because they have to. But flows pretty good despite this.

We averaged 15-20mph, which sounds slow, but gets you around the tiny 35-square mile island in no time. In fact, the only time we encountered gridlock was when two locals — headed in opposite directions — stopped to chat. With no way to drive around them, traffic backed up for two miles in each direction.

Sint Maarten
There's a huge cruise ship directly behind the red roof. Honestly, I could've taken this photo in Bali, too.

We head to the Dutch side of the island.

The Kangaroo place. It was hot out.

Following the arrow labeled “Dutch Side” sent us through Phillipsburg and, had we kept going, the airport. Phillipsburg, the Dutch “capital” of St. Martin, is a town so overdeveloped and tacky, it may have well been in the U.S. (In fact, if no one had told us it was Dutch, we would've had no way to know as no one ever spoke Dutch and there wasn't a single Dutch word on any signs.) It, in no way, resembled Amsterdam or other Dutch place we'd ever visited.

The area had all the typical tourist stuff you find at all cruise ship port cities, short of a Planet Hollywood. One notable exception to the fast-food and tourist-traps was the Kangaroo Court Caffe, a Fodor's-recommended place that didn't disappoint. If you're going, stop in.

We then drove to the French side of the island.

Orient Bay seen from Paradise View restaurant.

Following the “French Side” sign sent us north along the water to Orient Bay in Sint Maarten, an adorable residential beach town with what we took to be expensive-looking winter housing for rich, French people. Oddly, none of the roofs on the houses were the same color, those crazy French.

Further up the road, you arrive at Grand Case whether you want to or not (see earlier comment about number of roads). Grand Case consists of two one-way roads running in opposite directions along a sweet stretch of white, sandy beach. Nearly every structure on Sint Maarten's beach-side seemed to be a killer restaurant with a view of lapping waves and the British island, Anguilla, while the inland side seemed to be all vacation rentals.

Sint Maarten
Le Grand Case. (Note British island Anguilla on horizon.)

Continuing counter-clockwise around the island, the road leads into Marigot, the largest town on the French side of Sint Maarten. The Dutch influence in Phillipsburg was far less evident than the French influence in Marigot.

Here, people spoke French first, and then English if you stared at them blankly for long enough. There were numerous high-end shops offering vacationing Parisians all the comforts of home, duty-free. Needless to say, Amy wiped out shelves in a frenzied buying spree that raised the island's GNP a full percentage point for the year.

Le Pessoir, in Grand Case. Note actual “press” out the window.

The best restaurants on Sint Maarten were, not surprisingly, on the French side. Grand Case, in particular, had amazing restaurants such as Claude Mini-Club, Le Pressoir (The Press), and The Rainbow. But there were some good places inland, too. Like the quirky Yvette's, which was located in a converted house.

“Converted” may be a bit generous, since it looked like they merely removed all the furniture from the living room and replaced it with a bunch of tables. The decor was bright, yet shabby, but the food was impressive. Once again, had it not been for Fodor's, we would've certainly missed it.

Sint Maarten's motto seemed ludicrous at first.

Sint Maarten
Busby's outdoor café on Dawn Beach.

One thing that I found extremely odd about St. Martin was the island motto, visible on most license plates: The Friendly Island. This struck me as ludicrous and the height of over-promising (especially after some message-board postings I'd read that cast the island's safety into question). But then we experienced it first-hand. Repeatedly.

Sint Maarten
Wow! A French waiter took our picture without spitting on us.

Never before have I vacationed anywhere more genuine and accommodating. (In fact, the guys at the OBBR front gate were so friendly they let everyone in, rendering their jobs more than a little superfluous). And it wasn't just folks in the service industry. Nearly everyone we talked to or encountered was happy and helpful. Even on the French side. Yeah, unprecedented. I was stunned.

Sint Maarten is a great Caribbean island.

In the end, St. Martin/Sint Maarten was a great choice. It was nice to visit a foreign country that didn't hate Americans for a change. We had little difficulty dealing with the cultural differences of the two sides because almost everyone spoke English.

Sint Maarten
Some protected park on the French side.

Right down to the French-side waiters, a nice change from the hoity-toity ones we dealt with in Paris making Sint Maarten a sort of “France-Light” (all the food, half the attitude). In only one small market did we run into women who didn't speak English (or at least pretended not to).

Still, we were able to purchase rum, a pastry and éclairs with nothing more than pointing gestures, pleading looks and cold, hard American cash. Money proved not to be an issue either. Both sides happily took US cash, and most Dutch places gave it back as change.

But you had to use exact change on the French side if you didn't want to get back a handful of Euros. In all, Sint Maarten was a great place that I would heartily recommend over Jamaica. Unless you're looking for drugs, I guess.

Like these words?

Get notified when I post more of them—once a month, at most).