Maybe they deserved it. Another take on the Columbine shooting.

Maybe they deserved it. Another take on the Columbine shooting.

There's been a lot of boo-hooing over the Columbine, CO shooting lately, and much of it is warranted. After all, kids died. And I don't want to downplay the severity of the tragedy. It is awful, and my hearts go out to those innocents whose lives were needlessly cut short. I certainly wouldn't want any of my loved ones to be killed by some enraged high school student. The heinous actions of the shooters obviously point an accusing finger at the lack of parental supervision these kids received (How could you not know your kids were building bombs in the garage! What did they think they were doing? Tidying up?). But many other factors played into this as well. Saying the bad parents are solely at fault is too simplistic. Even taking into account the more violent-laden society we live in doesn't fully explain the slaughter. So I'll try.

Outraged parents are looking to find a cause of this suburban anomaly. A writer at Salon Magazine astutely pointed out that if the shooting had occurred in the 'hood, it would've only been covered on page 12 in the local Denver paper because it wouldn't have surprised anyone. But since it happened in a white school, suddenly it's a morality crisis in America.

Certain overzealous types blame the carnage on video games and want to ban them because a few unstable individuals couldn't distinguish between real life and fantasy life (one of the first signs of psychosis, if I'm not mistaken).

As a former public high school student, I have another possible theory on what caused this angered outburst: Maybe, just maybe, the students that got shot—and I apologize to my parents for this unsavory choice of words—were assholes. WHAT? Am I suggesting that perhaps some of the VICTIMS of this shooting were in part responsible for, or even the cause of, their own demise? Well, like I said, maybe.

The media has depicted the victims as perfect innocents minding their own business when some evil lunatic kids opened fire on them. C'mon, I went to public school and the only kids who were that innocent rode on the short bus and wore hockey gear year 'round. If those kids had been killed, then yeah, I'd buy the blameless kids bit. But the one thing anyone who's ever been through the gauntlet of public education knows is that Darwinism—whether it's taught in the school or not—rules supreme. It's survival of the fittest at its best. The good-looking guys get the good-looking girls. The stronger kids get to extort lunch money from the weaker ones.

When I was a freshman in high school, I stood all of 5'4". And I was hardly what you'd call "stocky". I was just a skinny kid with the glasses. I was the archetypal school-bully victim (I had bullies from other schools lining up to harass me). The only thing I lacked was Einstein-like math skills. There were any number of Neanderthals at my school who, even though they didn't know what Neanderthal meant, knew they could beat me up with impunity and used that limited knowledge to make my life totally suck.

I was the butt of mean-spirited practical jokes and general, all-around juvenile torment. I was in a fight or two, but after losing them, I learned quickly that fighting back only gave them license to really vent their "I'm not a homo" self-denial frustrations—a losing proposition in my opinion. Oh, sure I could've reported their actions to my parents or the school, but then I didn't want to feel what wearing a full-body cast was like. Therefore, conflict avoidance became the way to survive between 9am and 3pm.

But, let's say these kids weren't any good at conflict avoidance. And maybe they thought taking the "Joe Weider" approach of going home, working out and coming back to kick some Bully butt wouldn't work against the entire football team. THEN what?

Well, they'd be stuck. The frustration of the situation could easily make them desperate. Combine that out-of-control feeling with a few handy firearms and pipe-bombs and you've got the makings of a small scale invasion. Sure, killing others seems extreme, but kids have been known to go as far as kill themselves to escape life's problems. Suicide has always been prevalent among troubled teens. These kids just decided to take their problems out with them.

This is not to say that I condone their actions, I don't. Only that I understand where they could have come from. When guys who have all the cards— girls, money, looks, athleticism— make life a living hell for those who don't, society can't seriously expect them to sit there and take it. This IS America, after all. Land of self-sufficient tough guys with big guns who don't get mad, they get even.

Who knows why the kids shot up the school. Did those kids deserve to die? Probably not. Would the shooters beg to differ? I think so. Something pretty bad made those kids mad enough to kill.

Still, maybe some good will come of this tragedy. Maybe the shooters will become martyrs for all the little guys who are beaten up, bullied and ostracized by the big guys. Maybe it will cause spoiled, genetically blessed pricks to think twice (okay, at all): "Hey, this guy I'm tormenting for fun might go ballistic someday and kill me if I give him one more wedgie."

That wouldn't be all bad.

Comments

I have to agree

It is inevitable that the abused bullied will eventually lash out. Our country was built on the idea that rebellion and armed resistance is the way to go, how can we be hypocritical as to condemn these kids for doing what they had to. I was damn happy when I heard those guys killed those kids. I was damn near clapping for them, for finally striking fear in the hearts of those bullies. It must have been great to see them shaking in their letter jackets. They did have it comming and no one... NO ONE.... did not deserve it because you just know the ones that stood by and watched these kids get tormented everyday were just as guilty. I hope that sort of thing happens more and more so that one day just before a bully chooses his target he has to think twice about it.

Damn right

You're damn right they deserved it. And they're burning in Hades. The shooters were devine soliders striking down the wicked. Things had better change in schools. If not, HE will send more.

Funny little mental game.

Let's suppose you were in a concentration camp and you were beaten, whipped with belts, spat upon, punched, lodged in a locker, and threatened every day for 4 to 8 years day in and day out. Would society support the rebellion and killing of those who oppressed the weak? I argue yes. If we supported killing the Nazis and nuking the Japananese for torturing American soldiers during WWII then how is this any different. Some will say this is extreme but take away the nation state and take away the concentration camp and replace that with an American highschool and there is little difference between the two. May god bless Eric Harris and Dylan Cleabole.

Post new comment

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> fieldset legend h6 span img div p
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You may use [inline] tags to display contents inline.
  • You may quote other posts using [quote] tags.

More information about formatting options

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.